Heavy users are rarely a surprise. The surprise is how late you hear about them. By the time customers complain that evenings are slow, the biggest lines have been running hot for weeks, and the evidence is a router graph that nobody tied to a name.
A fair-use rule is easy to write down and hard to apply. Someone has to know how much each customer has used since the cycle began, notice who has passed the limit, slow them down, and remember to undo it when the cycle starts again. Done by hand, it happens when somebody has time.
P8 ISP adds up each subscriber's usage from RADIUS accounting, compares it with the policy you set, and slows the line when the limit is passed. When the window resets, the slowdown is lifted. You can see every subscriber's state on one screen.